As child vaccine rates slip, local health officials fight misinformation

OKLAHOMA CITY — By the summer of 2021, Phil Maytubby, deputy CEO of the Health Department here, was concerned to see the numbers of people getting vaccinated against Covid slipping after an initially robust response.

With doubt, fear and misinformation running rampant nationwide — both online and offline — he knew the agency needed to rethink its messaging strategy.

So the Health Department conducted something called an online “sentiment search,” which gauges how certain words are perceived on social media. The tool found that many people in Oklahoma City didn’t like the word “vaccinate” — a word featured prominently in the health department’s marketing campaign.

“If you don’t know how your message is resonating with the public,” Maytubby said, “you’re shooting in the dark.”

Oklahoma City County Health Department Deputy CEO Phil Maytubby.
Oklahoma City County Health Department Deputy CEO Phil Maytubby.Nick Oxford for KHN

Across the country, health officials have been trying to combat misinformation and restore trust within their communities these past few years, a period when many people haven’t put full faith in their state and local health departments. Agencies are using Twitter, for example, to appeal to niche audiences, such as NFL fans in Kansas City and “Star Wars” enthusiasts in Alabama. They’re collaborating with influencers and celebrities such as Stephen Colbert and Akbar Gbajabiamila to extend their reach.

Some of the efforts have paid off. By now, more than 80% of U.S. residents have received at least one shot of a Covid vaccine.

But data suggests that the skepticism and misinformation surrounding Covid vaccines now threaten other public health priorities. Flu vaccination coverage among children in mid-December was about the same as in December 2021, but it was 3.7 percentage points lower compared with late 2020, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The decrease in flu vaccination coverage among pregnant women is even more dramatic over the past two years: 18 percentage points.

Other common childhood vaccination rates are down, too, compared with pre-pandemic levels. Nationally, 35% of all American parents oppose requiring children to be vaccinated for measles, mumps and rubella before entering school, up from 23% in 2019, according to a KFF survey released Dec. 16. Suspicion swirling around once-trusted vaccines, as well as fatigue from so many shots, is likely to blame.

Maytubby, center, meets with Oklahoma City County Health Department staff members to review data on Covid case numbers and hospitalizations.
Maytubby, center, meets with Oklahoma City County Health Department staff members to review data on Covid case numbers and hospitalizations. Nick Oxford for KHN

Part of the problem is a lack of investment that eroded the public health system before the pandemic began. An analysis conducted by KHN and The Associated Press found local health department spending dropped by 18% per capita from 2010 to 2020. State and local health agencies also lost nearly 40,000 jobs from the 2008 recession to the emergence of the pandemic.

That made their response to a once-in-a-century public health crisis challenging and often inadequate. For example, during Covid’s early days, many local health departments used fax machines to report case counts.

“We were not as flexible as we are now,” said Dr. Brannon Traxler, director of public health at the South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Control.

At the start of the pandemic, Traxler said, only two people worked on the media relations and public outreach team at South Carolina’s health department. Now, the team has eight.

The agency has changed its communication strategies in other ways, too. This is the first year, for example, that South Carolina has published data on flu vaccinations every two weeks, with the goal of raising awareness about the effectiveness of the shots. In South Carolina, not even one-quarter of adults and children who are eligible for flu shots had been vaccinated by early December, even as flu cases and hospitalizations climbed. The flu vaccination rate across all age groups in the U.S. was 51.4% last season.

Those who have opted out of both the Covid and the flu shots seem to be correlated, Traxler said.

“We’re really just trying to dispel misinformation that’s out there,” Traxler said. To that end, the health department has partnered with local leaders and groups to encourage vaccinations. Agency staffers have also become more comfortable talking to the media, she said, to better communicate with the public.

But some public health experts argue that agencies are still failing on messaging. Scientific terms such as “mRNA technology,” “bivalent vaccine” and “monoclonal antibodies” are used a lot in public health, even though many people find them difficult to understand.

A study published by JAMA found that Covid-related language used by state-level agencies was often more complex than an eighth-grade reading level and harder to understand than the language commonly used by the CDC.

“We have to communicate complex ideas to the public, and this is where we fail,” said Brian Castrucci, CEO of the de Beaumont Foundation, a charitable group focused on strengthening public health. “We have to own the fact that our communication missteps created the environment where disinformation flourished.”

Most Americans support public health, Castrucci said. At the same time, a small but vocal minority pushes an anti-science agenda, and it has been effective in sowing seeds of distrust, he said.

Misinformation has changed everything.

 Phil Maytubby, Oklahoma city County health department

The more than 3,000 public health departments nationwide stand to benefit from a unified message, he said. In late 2020, the foundation, working with other public health groups, established the Public Health Communications Collaborative to amplify easy-to-understand information about vaccines.

“The good guys need to be just as well organized as those who seek to do harm to the nation,” he said. “One would think we would learn from this.”

Meanwhile, a report published in October by the Pew Research Center found 57% of U.S. adults believe “false and misleading information about the coronavirus and vaccines has contributed a lot to problems the country” has faced amid the pandemic.

“I was leery like everyone else,” said Davie Baker, 61, an Oklahoma City woman who owns a business that sells window treatments. When the shots became widely available in 2021, she thought they had been developed too quickly, and she worried about some of the things she’d read online about side effects. A pharmacist at Sam’s Club changed her mind.

“She just kind of educated me on what the shot was really about,” Baker said. “She cleared up some things for me.”

Oklahoma City resident Davie Baker.
Oklahoma City resident Davie Baker.Nick Oxford for KHN

Baker signed up for her first Covid shot in May 2021, around the same time the Health Department in Oklahoma City noticed the number of vaccine shots administered daily was starting to decline.

The department updated its marketing campaign in early 2022. Instead of using the word “vaccinate” to encourage more people to get their Covid shots — the word the agency’s social media analytics revealed people didn’t like — the new campaign urged people to “Choose Today!”

“People don’t trust like they used to,” Maytubby said. “They want to make up their own minds and make their own decisions.”

The word “choose” acknowledged that preference, he said.

Maytubby thinks the “Choose Today!” campaign worked. A survey of 502 adults in Oklahoma City conducted during the first half of 2022 found fewer than 20% of respondents reacted negatively or very negatively to a sample of “Choose Today!” advertisements. And an estimated 86.5% of adults in Oklahoma City have received at least one dose of a Covid vaccine — a rate higher than the state average of about 73%.

Other factors are most likely at play that have helped bolster Oklahoma City’s vaccination numbers. In the same survey of Oklahoma City adults, some people who had recently been vaccinated said that family members or church leaders urged them to get the vaccine or that they knew someone who had died from Covid. One person said money was the motivation, having received $900 from work to get the vaccine.

Meanwhile, the war against misinformation and disinformation rages on. Childhood vaccination rates for the immunizations students typically need to enter kindergarten are down 4.5% in Oklahoma County since the 2017-18 academic year as parents increasingly seek exemptions to the requirements.

That worries Maytubby. He said the primary tactic among those trying to sow distrust about vaccinations has been to cast doubt — about everything from the science to their safety.

“In that aspect, they’ve been pretty successful,” Maytubby said. “Misinformation has changed everything.”

Kaiser Health News and NBC News teamed up to produce this story.